DPC Directory

You have direct primary care and need the ER, the hospital or a specialist: what happens and who pays

DPC Directory Editorial

The short answer: your direct primary care (DPC) membership does not pay for the emergency room, a hospital stay or a specialist. Your health insurance does, if you have it, and you do if you don't. What the membership gives you on that path is a doctor you can often reach first, who can help you decide where to go, send a referral, and pick up your care when you come home. Federal rules protect you at the ER whether or not you have insurance, and there are specific steps that lower the bill if you don't.

People who join a DPC practice usually ask this before they join, or in the middle of the night: "I have a membership, so what happens now?" This article walks the path in the order you meet it. It is general information, not medical, legal or insurance advice. In an emergency, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room. Don't wait to reach your doctor.

1. Before you go: your DPC doctor, urgent care or the ER?

A DPC membership is a monthly fee paid straight to a primary care practice. Many practices let members call, text or message the doctor, sometimes after hours, and offer same-day or next-day visits. That changes the first step for problems that are urgent but not emergencies: a cut that may need stitches, a urinary infection, a child's ear pain, a sprain, a rash. Your DPC doctor can often see you, treat you in the office or tell you where to go.

What a practice offers after hours differs. Ask before you need it:

  • Can I reach the doctor at night and at weekends, and how (phone, text, app)?
  • Who covers when the doctor is away?
  • Which urgent care centers and hospitals do you send patients to?

See Can I see my DPC doctor same-day for urgent issues?

Go straight to the ER, or call 911, for chest pain, trouble breathing, signs of a stroke, severe bleeding, a serious injury, or anything that feels like an emergency. HealthCare.gov defines an emergency medical condition as "an illness, injury, symptom or condition so serious that a reasonable person would seek care right away to avoid severe harm" (HealthCare.gov glossary). You don't need your DPC doctor's permission or a referral to go.

2. At the emergency room

The hospital must see you. Under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), a Medicare-participating hospital with an emergency department must give anyone who asks a medical screening examination for a possible emergency, and stabilizing treatment for an emergency condition, "regardless of an individual's ability to pay" (CMS: EMTALA). That applies whether you are insured, uninsured or a DPC member.

If you have insurance, it pays as it would for anyone. Your DPC membership doesn't change your insurance. Bring your insurance card; the hospital bills your plan, and your deductible, copays and coinsurance apply. Two protections help:

  • No prior approval. HealthCare.gov says Marketplace plans "can't require you to get prior approval before getting emergency room services," and can't charge you more for emergency room services at an out-of-network hospital (HealthCare.gov: getting emergency care). Job-based plans and other individual plans have to cover emergency care without prior approval too, under the No Surprises Act rules (45 CFR 149.110); check your plan if it is a short-term or other non-ACA plan.
  • No surprise out-of-network bills for emergency care. Under the No Surprises Act, you can't be charged more for emergency services than your plan's in-network cost-sharing, and you're protected from unexpected out-of-network bills for care after you are stabilized unless you agree in writing to out-of-network care. For emergency room visits, providers aren't allowed to ask you to give up those protections (CMS: know your rights when using insurance).

The gap to know about: ground ambulances. CMS says "generally, ground ambulance services aren't covered by billing protections in the No Surprises Act" (same page). Air ambulances are covered. Some states have their own ground ambulance rules; your state insurance department can tell you.

Tell the ER who your doctor is. Give the DPC practice's name and number as your primary care doctor, and ask the hospital to send the visit notes and results there.

3. If you are admitted to the hospital

A DPC doctor may work only in the office and not admit or treat patients in the hospital. Inside the hospital, a hospital doctor (often called a hospitalist) usually runs your care. Ask your practice whether its doctor has hospital privileges anywhere; some may.

What your DPC doctor can usually still do:

  • Talk to the hospital team about your history, medicines and allergies, if you or your family let them know you've been admitted.
  • Help you and your family understand what the hospital team is proposing.
  • See you soon after you go home.

The bill for the stay goes to your insurance. Hospitalization is one of the essential health benefits every Marketplace plan must cover (HealthCare.gov: what Marketplace plans cover), with your deductible and cost-sharing. Short-term and other non-ACA plans may exclude or cap hospital care, so read the plan documents. This is the main reason a membership is not a replacement for insurance; see Do I still need health insurance with direct primary care?

4. After you go home

The days after a hospital stay or ER visit are where a DPC membership is most useful, and at many practices the visits are included in your monthly fee (ask what is not):

  • A follow-up visit soon after discharge, with time to go through what happened.
  • Medicines. Hospitals often start, stop or change prescriptions. Bring every bottle and the discharge papers so your doctor can check the list against what you were taking before.
  • Results that come back late, such as biopsy or culture results, and tests the hospital asked you to arrange.
  • Your records. You have a right to a copy of your hospital records under the federal HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) Privacy Rule; the hospital must generally act on a written request within 30 days (45 CFR § 164.524). Asking the hospital to send them to your DPC practice saves you a step.

5. Specialists, imaging and tests

A DPC membership doesn't pay for specialists; your insurance does, or you pay the specialist. See Does direct primary care cover specialist visits?

Referrals. Some plans, especially health maintenance organization (HMO) plans, pay for a specialist only with a referral. HealthCare.gov defines a referral as "a written order from your primary care doctor for you to see a specialist or get certain medical services," and notes that in many HMOs "you need to get a referral before you can get medical care from anyone except your primary care doctor. If you don't get a referral first, the plan may not pay for the services" (HealthCare.gov glossary). Many DPC doctors don't take insurance, so they may not be in your plan's network. If your plan requires referrals, call it before you book a specialist and ask:

  1. Do I need a referral for this specialist?
  2. Does it have to come from the primary care provider listed on my plan, or will you accept one from my DPC doctor?
  3. Is the specialist, imaging center or lab in network?

If your plan insists on its own primary care provider, you may need to name one on the plan as well as seeing your DPC doctor.

Paying cash. For imaging and lab tests, some DPC practices have arranged cash prices with local labs and imaging centers, which can be lower than what you would pay before meeting a high deductible. Ask for the cash price in writing before you go. A cash payment may not count toward your insurance deductible, so for a large bill compare both.

6. If you have DPC and no insurance

This is where the risk is. A hospital stay is expensive, and the membership pays none of it. If you are uninsured or decide not to use insurance:

  • Ask for a good faith estimate for planned care. If you don't have or use health insurance, providers must give you a good faith estimate of what scheduled care will cost when you book it at least 3 business days ahead, and you can ask for one directly. You won't get an estimate for emergency care (CMS: know your rights without insurance).
  • Dispute a bill that's well over the estimate. If a provider or facility charged at least $400 more than its good faith estimate, you can start a dispute within 120 calendar days of the first bill, for a $25 fee (CMS: dispute a bill).
  • Ask the hospital for financial assistance. A tax-exempt (nonprofit) hospital must have a written financial assistance policy that sets out who qualifies for free or discounted care and how to apply (IRS: financial assistance policies). If you qualify, it must limit charges for emergency and other medically necessary care to no more than the amounts generally billed to people who have insurance (IRS: limitation on charges). Each hospital sets its own income cutoffs, and federal law does not require free care. Ask for the policy and the application even after you get a bill.
  • Ask for an itemized bill and a self-pay price. Many hospitals offer a discount for paying cash, or a payment plan.
  • Look at coverage now, not after. Outside Open Enrollment you can buy a Marketplace plan only if you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period, for example after losing other health coverage (HealthCare.gov: Special Enrollment Period). Falling ill or going into hospital is not one of the listed events, so the time to sort out coverage is before you need it. See Can I use direct primary care without health insurance? and What is catastrophic health insurance, and why does it pair with DPC?

7. Who this works well for, and who should be careful

DPC with insurance works well for people who want quick access to a doctor who knows them, and help finding their way through the rest of the system. It does not reduce what your insurance charges you for a hospital stay, and it does not cover the specialists, scans and drugs a serious illness needs.

Be careful if you have a condition that already needs a specialist, regular imaging or expensive drugs. Make sure your insurance covers those before you rely on a DPC doctor to coordinate them, and check that your plan accepts their referrals. If you are weighing an employer plan built around DPC, see Your employer offers a DPC plan instead of insurance: what to check before you enroll.

Find a direct primary care practice in your state, and ask about after-hours access and referrals before you join.

Sources

This is general information, not medical, legal or insurance advice. Insurance plans, hospital policies and practice terms differ, so check your own plan and ask your practice.

Questions

Does my direct primary care membership pay for the emergency room or a hospital stay?

No. A direct primary care membership covers primary care from your practice for a monthly fee. It does not pay for emergency room visits, hospital stays, surgery, specialists or most imaging. Your health insurance pays for those under its normal deductible and cost-sharing, or you pay if you are uninsured. Your DPC doctor can often help you decide where to go, and can see you for follow-up after you go home.

Do I need my DPC doctor's permission or a referral to go to the ER?

No. In an emergency, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room. Under federal law, Marketplace, other individual and most job-based health plans can't require prior approval for emergency room services (short-term and other non-ACA plans may differ; check your plan), and a hospital with an emergency department that takes part in Medicare must screen and stabilize you regardless of your ability to pay. For urgent problems that are not emergencies, calling your DPC doctor first can save a trip.

Will my insurance accept a referral from a direct primary care doctor?

It depends on your plan. Many HMOs require a referral from your primary care doctor before they pay for a specialist, and some only accept one from the primary care provider listed on the plan. Many DPC doctors are not in insurance networks. Call your plan before you book a specialist and ask whether it accepts a referral from your DPC doctor and whether the specialist is in network.

I have DPC but no insurance and ended up in the hospital. What can I do about the bill?

Ask the hospital for its financial assistance policy and apply, even after you get the bill. A nonprofit hospital must have one, and if you qualify it must limit charges for emergency and medically necessary care to what it generally bills insured patients. Ask for an itemized bill, a self-pay discount or a payment plan. Each hospital sets its own cutoffs, and federal law does not require free care. For planned care, ask for a good faith estimate; if the bill is at least $400 above it, you can start a dispute within 120 days of the first bill. This does not apply to emergency care, where no estimate is given.